To no one’s surprise, Hulu’s hit series Only Murders in the Building, which premiered in 2021, became an instant success. The show not only captured attention due to our collective obsession with true crime and the star-studded cast including Selena Gomez, Steve Martin, and Martin Short, but also because of the stylish fashion showcased throughout the series. From Tie-Dye Guy’s colorful hoodie to Mabel Mora’s (Selena’s character) fabulous outfits, such as the gold necklace she wears in multiple episodes, the fashion in the show has made a lasting impression.
If you’ve been wanting to recreate Selena’s iconic looks from Only Murders in the Building, we’ve gathered affordable alternatives inspired by her wardrobe from seasons 1, 2, and 3. In celebration of the release of the first two episodes of season 3, here are some dupes that will help you achieve Mabel’s fashionable closet.
In season 3, episode 2, Selena’s character rocks a sparkly ensemble that combines Bob Fosse vibes with a New Year’s Eve look. She pairs a business-like jacket with sequins, sheer tights, and black stilettos to create a sexy outfit. To achieve a similar style, check out the following pieces: & Other Stories Sequin Statement Jacket, Sheertex Classic Sheer Rip-Resist Tights, and CXQRR Black Bowler Derby Hat.
In season 3, episode 1, Mabel knows that a chic outfit is incomplete without a good coat. Her beige trench coat has the power to pull together any look, whether it’s a mix of colorful statement pieces or a preppy sweater vest/button-up combination. To recreate this look, consider the following items: Amazon Essentials Long Sleeve Button Down Oxford Shirt, Gorjana Parker Huggie Earrings (18K Gold Plated).
Season 2, episode 5 features Selena in the perfect argyle cardigan, fulfilling all of our dark academia dreams. It’s a versatile piece that can elevate a simple crop-top-and-jeans combo. To achieve a similar look, try the Design History Argyle Cropped Cardigan, Susana Monaco Thin Strap Crop Tank, Madewell Perfect Vintage Wide-Leg Crop Jean, and Laura Lombardi Spira Gold-Tone Hoop Earrings.
In season 2, episode 3, chunky loafers take center stage in Mabel’s outfit. While her exact sweater from Lisa Says Gah! may be sold out, you can find a great checkered alternative that captures the same energy. Pair it with the Rellery Marigold necklace for a complete look. Consider the Dressed in Lala Love You Checkerboard Oversize Cardigan, Steve Madden Lando Black Leather loafers, and Rellery Marigold Initial Necklace.
Season 2, episode 1 showcases Mabel’s style icon status from the start. Her black fur poncho is a standout piece that can be easily replicated with a similar-looking option that won’t break the bank. Check out the ZESICA Turtleneck Chunky-Knit Oversized Sweater, Dynamite Ellie Pleated Wide Leg Pants, Madewell Carina Platform Chelsea Boots, and ASOS Jayley Double Layer Faux Fur Trim Cape.
In season 1, episode 1, Mabel’s now-famous orange coat and checkered pants combo set the bar high for the rest of Selena’s looks. Recreate this eye-catching outfit with J. Crew Featherweight Cashmere Cropped Cardigan Sweater, Connectyle Warm Winter Beanie, and Madewell Perfect Vintage Straight Jean.
Season 1, episode 2 features Selena rocking a red jumpsuit, adding her unique touch to the look. Consider the Quince Cotton Linen Twill Short Sleeve Coverall Jumpsuit, Alo Yoga Sherpa Trench in Camel, Call It Spring Chelsea Boots, and The Branch Soft Extra-Long Heavy Slouch Socks to achieve a similar standout outfit.
Pairing a simple turtleneck with a fun skirt is a foolproof combination, as seen in season 1, episode 3. Recreate this effortlessly cute black and khaki ensemble with a black turtleneck, a skirt of your choice, and either combat boots for a casual vibe or shiny patent heels for a fancier feel.
Season 1, episode 7 showcases Mabel’s versatility as she trades in her camp theme for a sleeker aesthetic. This outfit, featuring trousers, booties, and a long coat, is perfect for a job interview or a dinner date. Consider the Everlane Silky Cotton Way-Short Shirt, Calvin Klein Classic Fit Straight Leg Suit Pant, and Maison Earth-Tone Belted Wool Coat for a similar sophisticated look.
Finally, in season 1, episode 10, Mabel’s academia-inspired look steals the show. From the cozy top to the plaid mini skirt, this outfit is effortlessly stylish. To achieve a similar vibe, try the Tuckernuck Cream Shaker Turtleneck Sweater, Lulus Cutest Lesson Brown Plaid High-Rise Mini Skirt, and Luv AJ Baby Amalfi Tube Hoop Earrings.
Selena’s character in Only Murders in the Building has inspired us to embrace statement coats, business professional looks, cozy knits, and bold color choices. By incorporating elements from her wardrobe into your own, you can channel Mabel’s fabulous style in a budget-friendly way.